What is Podcast Reviews?
Podcast reviews are written feedback and ratings listeners leave on platforms like Apple Podcasts and Podchaser. Reviews provide social proof for potential subscribers and may influence chart rankings and directory visibility.
Where Reviews Live
| Platform | Review Type | Visibility |
|---|---|---|
| Apple Podcasts | Star rating + written | High (millions of users) |
| Podchaser | Star rating + written | Growing (podcast-focused) |
| Spotify | Star rating only | Limited to Spotify users |
| Podcast Addict | Star rating + written | Android users |
| Goodpods | Social recommendations | Community-focused |
Review Anatomy
Apple Podcasts review:
- 1-5 star rating
- Review title (headline)
- Written review (body)
- Reviewer's Apple ID display name
- Date posted
Impact of Reviews
| Factor | Evidence |
|---|---|
| New listener decisions | Social proof influences subscribing |
| Chart rankings | Some correlation (not definitive) |
| Search visibility | Reviews may influence Apple's algorithm |
| Sponsor evaluation | Sponsors check review sentiment |
| Personal motivation | Feedback loop for creators |
Getting More Reviews
| Strategy | Effectiveness |
|---|---|
| Ask in episode (CTA) | Most effective |
| Ask in show notes | Moderate |
| Email newsletter ask | Good for engaged fans |
| Social media request | Lower conversion |
| Reading reviews on air | Encourages more reviews |
| Giveaways for reviewers | Works but may violate ToS |
Handling Negative Reviews
| Response | Rationale |
|---|---|
| Don't obsess | One negative among positives is normal |
| Look for patterns | Multiple similar complaints = real issue |
| Can't remove | Apple rarely removes reviews |
| Respond (where possible) | Shows you care (Podchaser) |
| Improve and move on | Best response is better content |
Why It Matters
Reviews are social proof—visible endorsements that help potential listeners decide whether to try your show. While their algorithmic impact is debated, their psychological impact on subscription decisions is real.
Why reviews matter:
-
Trust signal: 5-star ratings with positive reviews build credibility.
-
Decision factor: Many listeners check reviews before subscribing.
-
Feedback channel: Reviews tell you what listeners value (and don't).
-
Sponsor credibility: Advertisers evaluate review sentiment.
-
Creator morale: Positive reviews validate your work.
The review paradox: The listeners who would write the best reviews are often too busy enjoying your content to think about reviewing. That's why asking matters.
Review quantity benchmarks:
| Reviews | Perception |
|---|---|
| 0-10 | New show, limited social proof |
| 10-50 | Established, building audience |
| 50-200 | Solid credibility |
| 200-500 | Well-established show |
| 500+ | Major podcast |
Review quality vs quantity: 100 genuine 5-star reviews with thoughtful comments are more valuable than 500 generic "Great show!" reviews. Authenticity matters.
The rating reality: Most podcasts average 4.5-5 stars because only fans bother reviewing. A 4.0 rating is actually concerning—it means some people disliked it enough to say so publicly.